How long does Uncrustables last? [Avoid Food Poisoning]

How Long do Uncrustables last

I don’t know what the deal is with crusts. I like them when they are properly crisp and tasty. But a simple soggy crust is not the one I like.

And if you are like me, you would love yourself some uncrustables. Whether homemade or bought from the store, uncrustables are an interesting snack. 

You have bought some excess uncrustable packets from the store or made some at home and could not finish them.

In such situations, you would worry how long do uncrustables last? Is it okay to consume them after 2 days? And several such questions.

Generally, if you have observed, uncrustables last around 2 to 3 days but this time keeps changing with different circumstances. 

How long do Uncrustables Last? 

Uncrustables have a shelf life that lasts for a limited amount of time. It’s better if you consume them within this time frame. 

Once the uncrustables are brought, it is hard to have leftovers, but if there are any, their shelf-life depends on various factors.

Their shelf-life depends, on whether the uncrustable is homemade or bought from the store. 

It also depends on how and where you store your uncrustables. 

Let’s know more about the shelf life of uncrustables.

Don’t have time, here’s a quick table.

Uncrustables2 to 3 hours2 days1 to 2 months 

How long do Uncrustables last in Fridge?

The most simple way to store and assure the safety and quality of your uncrustable is by keeping them in the fridge. 

I guess you have made some uncrustable in the afternoon, and if there are some leftovers, you can easily store them in the fridge. 

You can easily enjoy them at night or the next day. This is because uncrustable last for around 2 and a maximum of 3 days in the fridge. 

After this period, the bread in your uncrustable will become stable and slowly go bad.

If you have bought some uncrustable from the store, you can keep them in the fridge. 

Just make sure to check the “Best By” date on their package. And remember that the “Best By” date determines the quality of the food product, not the safety. 

The most famous uncrustable company, “Smuckers,” say that their uncrustables would last around 2 days in the fridge once the packet is open. But they can stay out at room temperature for around 6 hours. 

How long does Uncrustables last in Fridge
Storing Uncrustables in Freezer

How long do Uncrustables last in Freezer?

As far as I know, uncrustables are one of the most famous frozen snacks ever. Some people even like to consume uncrustables when frozen. 

However you like to consume uncrustables, they are kept in their best condition when stored in the freezer. 

If you want to prepare a batch of uncrustables beforehand for upcoming days, you can easily do it by keeping your uncrustables in the freezer.

In the freezer, uncrustables would last around 1 to 2 months. After a month, your uncrustables will lose their original taste and texture, and you may not like them.

You can also store the store-bought uncrustables in the freezer. They also last for around 1 to 2 months in the freezer. For more information, you can always look up to the “Best By” date on the package.

How long is Uncrustables good after Expiration?

Uncrustables if you have bought them from the store, will have a certain expiration date written on them. 

After this date, it’s recommended not to consume them. But if you have been storing your uncrustables in the freezer for the entire time. Your uncrustables may stay in good condition longer than the expiration date.

After the expiration date, your uncrustables may last for 15 to 30 days if kept in the freezer. 

But it’s always wise to consume your uncrustables as soon as possible. Once they cross a certain time, their taste will vary drastically. 

How to Store Uncrustables? 

Uncrustables are quite an easy dish. It is simple to make and simple to store as well. You just need to remember some key points, and you will be all good to go. 

Firstly, if your uncrustables bought from the store are unopened, you should leave it alone and store them in the fridge. Make sure that you consume them within their expiration date. Don’t forget about your uncrustables. 

If you have opened your packet of uncrustables, remove them from the package. Either you can store them in an airtight container or a ziploc bag. Anything that is of your choice and convenience. 

Once you place them in a bag or a container, you can store them in uncrustables in the fridge if you’re going to consume them within 2 days. 

If not, then you should store them in the freezer. You can easily thaw them and enjoy it.

Packaged Uncrustables in Mall
Storing Uncrustables for Better Shelf Life

How long do Uncrustables last after Thawing?

You can eat your delicious uncrustables whenever you want. Just store them in the freezer and thaw them when you want to eat them.

But once your uncrustables are thawed, don’t refreeze them. It will ruin their texture, and there is a possibility of bacterial contamination. 

So, if you’re thawing your uncrustables at room temperature, it is wise to consume them within 6 to 8 hours. 

If you are thawing uncrustables by keeping them in the fridge, then you can consume it within 24 hours. But I have experienced consuming uncrustables within 8 hours.

How to tell if Uncrustables are bad? 

Uncrustables have a limited shelf-life. Like all other food items, uncrustables do go bad eventually. 

Here are some cues you need to know to recognize if your uncrustables have gone bad. 

If any mold or fungus grows on top of your uncrustables, you should throw it away as soon as possible. 

If your uncrustables don’t smell the same, do a taste check. If your uncrustables don’t taste the same, you should not consume them. 


I hope I have answered all your queries regarding how long your uncrustables would last and how you can store them for better preservation. 

It’s good if you freeze your uncrustables, and they will last longer. 

Similar Posts


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *